Niagara County Fair

2025 Pie & Brownie Competitions

THE RESULTS ARE IN!
PIE COMPETITION
WINNERS
Brownie COMPETITION
WINNERS
2025 homemade pie competition winners
Best in Show
Cherry
Cynthia mccarver
VIEW RECIPE
Cherry
1st Place
Cynthia McCarver
2nd Place
Jenelle Dengate
Berry
1st Place
Nick Kester
Grown in WNY
1st Place
Kathy Kindle
2nd Place
Katie Pfiefer &
Lauren Wright
3rd Place
Nick Kester
Apple
1st Place
Cynthia McCarver
2nd Place
Sylvia Gugino
3rd Place
Kellie Sonnenfeld
Peach
1st Place
Nick Kester
Savory
1st Place
Nick Kester
Cream
1st Place
Carol Petty
2nd Place
Abby Gratsa &
Beth Kaufman
Specialty
1st Place
Nick Kester
2nd Place
Rachel Becken
3rd Place
Cynthia McCarver
2025 Erie Canal Bicentennial Brownie
Competition winners
1st place
Cynthia mccarver
Amherst, NY
VIEW RECIPE
2nd place
Sylvia Gugino
Sanborn, NY
VIEW RECIPE
3rd place
Olivia Bidak
Lockport, NY
VIEW RECIPE

Rules & Entry Forms

Pie Competition Entry Form Brownie Competition Entry Form
For more info, contact:
Amanda Henning
Agriculture & Food Systems Team Leader
app27@cornell.edu
(716) 433-8839 ext. 231

Special Thanks To Our Sponsors

About the Fair Fair Schedule Contact Us Get Tickets
©2025 Cornell Cooperative Extension Niagara County. All Rights Reserved.